An odd little Contest...

[Zahir al Daoud]

Okay, suppose in the Buffyverse the truth about the Slayer and her exploits came out. And there was a hollywood movie made about it. Who would play who?

My list...

Willow = Michelle Williams
Tara = Alicia Witt
Buffy = Drew Barrymore
Giles = Alan Rickman
Xander = Freddie Prinze, Jr.
Anya = Thora Birch
Spike = Billy Idol
Drusilla = Angelina Jolie
Faith = Fairuza Balk
Angel = Gereint Wynn Davies (of "Forever Knight")
Cordelia = Neve Campbell
Dawn = Hmmmm....I just don't know.
Harmony = Uh...Reese Witherspoon?

What do you guys think?

[emma peel]

Interesting contest,Zahir al Daoud.
Maybe for Harmony..hmmm..Lisa Kudrow...Mira Sorvino..or Jenna Elfman.
For Dawn:can't think of anyone off the top of my head.
Janice

[xita]

My list as played by famous child actors,

[b:83da7b146e] when they were children[/b:83da7b146e]

Willow = Tatum O'Neil (from little darlings)
Tara = Kristy McNichol (from little darlings)
Buffy = Hallie Eisenberg (Pepsi Girl)
Giles = Anthony Michael Hall
Xander = Bug Hall AKA Alfalfa
Anya = Mayim Bialik (Blossom)
Spike = Macaulay Culkin
Drusilla = Kirsten Dunst (interview with a vampire)
Faith = Jodi Foster (taxi)
Angel = Haley Joel Osment (the sixth sense)
Cordelia = Mary-Kate Olsen
Dawn = Shirley Temple
Harmony = Ashley Olsen
Graham = Gary Coleman

[Warduke]

Oh god xita...rofl

That was so much fun, I made my own...

Heres my musical list

Willow = Tiffany
Tara = Debbie Gibson
Buffy = Christina Aguilera
Giles = Robert Palmer
Xander = Meatloaf
Anya = Kylie Minogue
Spike = Eminem
Drusilla = Cher
Faith = Alanis Morissette
Angel = Jon Bon Jovi
Cordelia = Victoria Adams (Posh Spice)
Dawn = Charlotte Church
Harmony = Britney Spears
Riley = Billy Ray Cirus
Joyce = Celine Dion (because shes the best mother in the whole world)

[relativegirl]

Dawn is easy. Lacy Chabert from Party o' 5. The only child actress annoying enough to pull off GET OUT GET OUT GET OUT!

[Bookcat]

Except, you know, Michelle Tratchenburg. But that's not the point.

[TyRex316]

Here's my little list:
Buffy=Jennifer Grey
Willow=Molly Ringwald
Tara=Mary Stuart Masterson
Xander=Emilio Estevez
Giles=Judge Rinehold
Angel=Judd Nelson
Spike=Jon Cryer
Faith=Demi Moore
Riley=Rob Lowe
Drusilla=Ally Sheedy

[xita]

God brian and ty you guys killed me!

On a side note, wasn't Lacy Chabert from Party o 5 up for Dawn. Was that not what I heard?

[Warduke]

That rocks Ty!

[Bookcat]

these are amusing me greatly. What fun, what fun. Good times. Many more positivie adjectives.

[Rally]

So many lists... so little time...

[Katharyn]

Back to Tiffany and Debbie Gibson...

Those two just keeping rearing their heads in connection with W/T...

Katharyn
--------------

[emma peel]

Warduke, Meatloaf and Eminem??What a combination that would make. They would get along really,really well (not) IMHO.
You guys have great imaginations!
Janice

[alyamber4ever]

It's hard for me to pick anyone else to play the different Buffy roles. To me, Nobody else can play Willow or Tara or Buffy.....and so on. I would have it no other way then how it is right now.

BTVS RULEZ

[AutumnT]

I'm going to mix it up and cast cross gender. Hee.

Buffy = Dean Cain
Willow = John Cusak
Tara = Matt Damon
Xander = Janeane Garafalo
Giles = Vanessa Redgrave
Dawn = Macaulay Culkin
Anya = Chris Rock
Cordy = Rob Lowe
Oz = Allison Janney
Spike = Courtney Love

[Rally]

Ok, here is the slightly more talented and mature 90's casting:

Buffy = Linda Hamilton
Willow = Susan Sarandon
Tara = Michelle Pfeiffer
Giles = Harrison Ford
Xander = Kurt Russell
Anya = Sigourney Weaver
Spike = Keifer Sutherland
Dawn = Diane Lane
Angel = Arnold Schwarzenegger
Cordy = Kim Cattrall
Oz = James Spader

[Bagheera]

Buffy=Samantha Janus
Willow=Charlotte Coleman (RIP )
Tara=Susannah Harker
Xander=Neil Morrissey
Giles=Jim Broadbent
Angel=Colin Firth
Spike=John Hannah
Faith=Julia Sawalha
Riley=Martin Clunes
Drusilla=Jennifer Ehle
Dawn=Nicola Blackwell
Joyce=Joanna Lumley
Cordelia=Saffron Burrows

[i:5fedf19771] Edited to add Cordelia, good suggestion btw![/i:5fedf19771]

[willow420]

I shall do Disney cartoon characters.

Willow = Ariel
Tara = Belle
Buffy = Tinkerbell
Giles = Mufasa
Xander = Tweedle Dumb
Oz= Tweedle Dee
Anya = Meg
Spike = Quausimodo
Drusilla = Alice
Faith = Mulan
Angel = Gaston
Cordelia = Jasmine
Dawn = Wendy

[emma peel]

Holy shit,AutumnT! Janeane Garafalo as Xander???? I
Janeane Garafalo! (but not in the way I love Amber).EWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!! How can you do that to Janeane!!!
Other than that, I think you have some very good choices.
Macaulay Culkin as Dawn.Hehe. (That emoticon reminds me of Macaulay in "Home Alone.").

Tee hee.
Janice

[Bagheera]

Buffy=Kym Wilson
Willow=Jacqueline McKenzie
Tara=Cate Blanchett
Xander=Ben Mendelsohn
Giles=Geoffrey Rush
Angel=Simon Westaway
Spike=Noah Taylor
Faith=Rachel Griffiths
Riley=One of the Daddos
Drusilla=Pamela Rabe
Dawn=Nikki Webster
Joyce=Sonia Todd
Cordelia=Nicole Kidman

[urnofosiris]

Hmm let's see
Well seeing as the Law Firm of Fish, Cage & McBeal has been disbanded they do need a new job:

Buffy = Ally "Sneeze and she will blow away" McBeal
Willow = Ling "The Wicked Witch from the West" Woo
Tara = Nelle "Lesbian Sex is Ew" Porter
Xander = Richard "Driven by the Dumbstick" Fish
Giles = John "The Nose Whistler Instead of Glass Cleaner" Cage
Anya = Elaine "Bad Luck With Men" Vassal
Spike = Claire "This is not my Natural Haircolor" Otoms
Oz = The Dancing Baby (Nuff said)
Cordelia = Georgia "Look at me I am Pretty" Thomas
Angel = Billy Allan "Bore Me to Death" Thomas

[Bagheera]

Rally: Sheer genius, you found someone with even less range than David Boring-as!
And plenty of W/T goodness with your pairing..mmmm
Though I think you're underusing Sigourney as Anya....

[Anita Iowa]

Ok, now that I'm getting over the idea of Tiffany and Debbie Gibson being cast as lovers (gah!), here's my no-particular-theme list (except, from off the top of my head right before bed):

Tara = Stevie Nicks
Giles = Ozzy Osbourne
Buffy = Martha Stewart
Xander = one of those guys that hosts "The Man Show"
'Dark Magick' Willow = Joan Rivers
Real Willow = Chelsea Clinton
Dawn = Marykate and Ashley Olson
Spike = Johnny Rotten
Drusilla = Mariah Carey
Anya = Wanda from Eonline
Harmony = Jenna Bush
Oz = Billie Joe from Green Day
Wesley = George Will
Cordelia = Cher
Kendra = Miss Cleo
Faith = Angelina Jolie
Angel = Bart Simpson (only actor they could find with the
same hairdo)
Fred = Christian Ricci
The Mayor = George W. Bush
Principal Snyder = Kenneth Lay
Riley Finn = Random Dept. Store Mannequin

[BytrSuite]

Xita, Brian, Ty, Autumn, Rally and Liz, you all are fairly brilliant. They're all just too funny.

Love those themed casts.

[mollyig]

Warduke's casting of Meat Loaf as Xander has me laughing still!

[ninjitsugrrl]

Oooh, this is fun. Some of these are cracking me up! I'm just going to throw in a bunch of random people I think are cute, fun, and/or amusing.

Willow = Kelly Osbourne, who's just too freakin' cute for words!
Tara = Julia Stiles
Buffy = Natalie Portman
Giles = Patrick Stewart
Joyce = Annabeth Gish
Xander = Jack Osbourne
Anya = Parker Posey
Spike = I'm writing Spike out of my version
Drusilla = Rose McGowan
Faith = Alyssa Milano
Angel = The guy who plays/played (not sure if he's still on) John Black on Days. He's very good at looking confused/tortured.
Cordelia = Christina Ricci
Dawn = The girl who plays Lucy on 7th Heaven b/c she's the only other actress that age I can think off

[Warduke]

Garfield, Autumn, Rally and Liz...too damn funny

[Elianna]

Ok, probably will only amuse me, but I decided to make a cast using only people who have appeared in silent movies, and Mel Brook's doesn't count.

Willow-Lillian Gish (one of the best actresses ever)
Anya - Jean Harlow (she counts, was in a silent short with Laurel and Hardy)
Buffy - Mary Pickford ( another sacharine role for her)
Dawn - Dorothy Gish (No reason, I just like her)
Xander - Harold Lloyd (my favorite actor, he could pull this off)
Giles - Edward Everet Horton (odd choice, I know)
Tara - Greta Garbo (yes, she was in silent films, too)
Riley - Douglas Fairbanks, Sr.
Spike - Oliver Hardy

Probably not the best that I can do, but it amused me! =)
-Elianna

[neroden1]

No... that's a *good* casting. That would be truly awesome.

All those actors have just the right talents.

[Zahir al Daoud]

OMG!!!

I am sooooooo LMAO!!!!!